my take on the friction between you two




Contract List
Thread 0 of 604
Healing Tao USA Practice Forum: Sharing Your Way Login or Register
Forum Search
User Search
Site Search
Practice Logs
Forum Quickstart Guide
Login
Qigong Fundamentals Fusion Healing Love Inner Alchemy Articles Bookstore
10 users logged on.
1 new posts today.
Practice
General Philosophy Frequently Asked Questions FREE Inner Smile Ebook Chapter Video Previews 11824516 accesses

about symbol

Get a Free $20. eBook!

Way of the Inner Smile
130 pages, 25 photos
Simple. easy. Deep.
Sign in for download.
Your privacy is protected.

Tao News – click to subscribe
From Micheal Winn
Frequently Asked Questions
Product Catalog
Sequence of Courses
Overview of Tao System
Articles: Qigong, Alchemy
Teaching Schedule
  Asheville & International
Who is Michael Winn?
China Dream Trip 2010
From Mantak Chia
Products
Healing Tao System
Other Products
Taoist Calligraphy
Tao T-shirts - very cool
I Ching Astrology
Taoist Flower Essences
Other Tao Products
Taoist Discussion
Search for Instructor
Instructor Sites
Taoist Bookstore
Taoist Links
Site Search
Contact Us
Healing Tao USA Goal
To unfold Tao, the Natural Way- the deep, embodied Natural Truth. To assist all beings experience their Whole, True, Original, and Immortal Self.

my take on the friction between you two

From: Steven
Subject: Practice
Date/Time 2010-08-17 13:31:52
Remote IP: 75.7.196.108

Message

Having read a number of recent exchanges between you and bagua,
I can sense a good deal of frustration coming through . . .

Part of the problem is, is that you two believe in different models.

Your model is one in which the individual is mortal, and by
doing the alchemical formulas of One Cloud, the process
transforms you into something else: a spiritually immortal being.

Bagua's model is one which the individual is immortal already,
and nothing needs to be done to make you immortal. All the
alchemy does is to release the cloud of attachment and confusion
that prevents you from living in a core space where you can
see this reality directly.

Then when the two of you argue, you are arguing from the perspective
of your model and he is arguing from his. So there becomes an incompatibility
between what you two are talking about.

Having gotten into arguments myself with both of you before, I've learned this
to be the case. You keep trying to fit things into your model, and
he keeps trying to fit things into his. It makes healthy discussion
difficult, as things keep going round and round in confusion until
either someone gets frustrated and gives up, or the underlying model
assumptions are brought to light.

And the fact that Bagua's style of arguing is based on having a
master's degree in "Socratic irony" doesn't help matters much. ;)

Peace,
S
[Top of List] [Previous Thread] [Next Thread]
This Forum is for posting on topics of interest to the Taoist (Daoist) community. Tao is exceptionally broad. Will your post add to the collective balance, harmony, & wisdom? Posts/links deemed obscene, prejudicial, irrelevant, inflammatory, or falsely impersonating others may be removed at Healing Tao USA's discretion. The Forum community thanks you for respecting the registration privilege!

Healing Tao USA Discussion Forums.

Login Here
NAME: To register for both Forums    CLICK HERE.
PASSWORD: To find your Logon Name or Password   CLICK HERE
Remember my Name and Password

Both Logon and Password are case sensitive
Disclaimer: Opinions expressed here may not be in agreement with those of Healing Tao USA Inc. and it's representatives. The above parties are not responsible in any manner whatsoever for any injury or health condition that may occur through following the opinions expressed here. Consult with your physician before starting any practice program.